No prop firm whose terms we read allows a passing service: all 8 rule sets from 7 firms, as of November 2026, forbid anyone but the account holder from trading the account, and 7 of the 8 put profits, rewards or refunds at stake on a breach. A passing service (a business that logs into your evaluation account and trades it until it passes, for a fee or a share of later payouts) also meets the firm's checks later than buyers expect.

Key takeaway

As of November 2026, all 8 rule sets we read from 7 prop firms ban anyone but the account holder from trading the account, and 7 of them tie a breach to forfeited profits, rewards or refunds. FTMO and FundedNext check identity before the funded account and Topstep again at payout, after both fees are paid. On an illustrative $550 outlay and a $1,000 first payout, the buyer needs better than a 55.0% chance of keeping it, a rate no firm publishes.

What is a prop firm passing service, and how does it get into your account?

A passing service trades your evaluation for you, so it needs the login that places orders, not a view-only one. You buy the evaluation in your name, hand over the credentials, and the service trades to the profit target. Some stop there; others keep trading the funded account for a cut of payouts.

Pages that rank these services claim an investor password is enough. MetaQuotes password help for MetaTrader 5 says otherwise: the investor password is "read-only" with "no trading operations", and only the master password gives "full access to the trading account".

The investor key opens a window onto balance, history and open positions, with no way to trade. The master key opens the door, and every order goes through it. A service that passes your evaluation must hold the second key, which is the third-party access the clauses below forbid.

TWO KEYS TO ONE ACCOUNT MT5 ACCOUNT balance history open positions BUY / SELL INVESTOR PASSWORD "read-only" "no trading operations" view only BUY / SELL no order goes through MASTER PASSWORD "full access to the trading account" orders A passing service must hold this key: third-party access, banned in all 8 Password roles: MetaQuotes, MetaTrader 5 password help.
A service cannot pass anything with a read-only password. If it trades, it holds your master login, which is the access every clause forbids.

Do prop firms allow passing services?

No. Every rule set we read bans a third party from trading or accessing your account, under labels such as third-party trading, account management, account sharing or trading on behalf of others, and The5ers prohibited practices page names Account Management Services "Pass your Challenge" outright.

The table sets each clause beside the stages it covers and the consequence it states.

Rule setClause wording (verbatim fragment)Stages coveredStated consequence
Topstep"Trading on behalf of others"Every level of the programDelete trading day and all profits, restart or close, ban
FTMO (CFD)"allow any third party to access or otherwise use"Challenge/Verification and FTMO AccountTrade removal, disqualification, forfeited Rewards, termination of all agreements
FTMO Futures"access, operate, or otherwise use"Evaluation and Live Funded AccountTrade removal, termination, forfeited rewards, permanent restriction
Tradeify"management of a Trader's account by or on behalf of any third party"Evaluation, Simulated Funded, Elite LiveEvery involved account in violation, profits forfeited, termination, permanent ban
FundedNext"accessed, operated, or traded by a third party"Any FundedNext accountPermanent termination, reward denied or adjusted, refund denied
The5ers"Pass your Challenge"Evaluation phases and Pro accountsRefund and profit not processed, permanent ban
Earn2Trade"to gain access to the evaluation account"Evaluation namedWarning, day deleted, reset or permanent closure
Elite Trader Funding"manage or execute trades on any Account"Any AccountRewards denied, suspension or termination

Compiled by Phoenix Technologies from each firm's own terms and help pages, read on 19 November 2026; method: each rule set classified by the stages its wording names and the consequences it states. Tally: 4 name both stages, 3 use any-account or every-level wording, 1 names the evaluation only, 7 state forfeited or denied profits, rewards or refunds, and 4 state a ban or permanent restriction.

According to FTMO forbidden trading practices, "You must not allow any third party to access or otherwise use your FTMO Account or your FTMO Challenge/Verification account". The FundedNext help center covers any account "accessed, operated, or traded by a third party or individual other than the registered account holder, whether paid or unpaid". Rules change, so check the firm's current terms before buying.

"Every firm bans it" is only partly proven. Apex Trader Funding, MyFundedFutures, Take Profit Trader, Lucid Trading and FundingPips blocked our fetches of their pages on 19 November 2026, so their clauses are not in the table.

Does the ban stop at the evaluation, or reach the funded account too?

It reaches the funded account in 7 of the 8 rule sets: 4 name both stages and 3 use wording that covers any account or every level of the program. A service that passes the evaluation cannot hand back a clean funded account.

Tradeify's Evaluation Services Agreement is the plainest: "These consequences apply equally to evaluation accounts, Simulated Funded Accounts, and Tradeify Elite Live accounts." The5ers says its ban "works both for our evaluation phases and Pro accounts", and FTMO Futures rules name the Live Funded Account. Earn2Trade's access clause names only the evaluation, but at checkout the buyer declares "that you are not trading on behalf of anyone else", according to the Earn2Trade terms and conditions.

Under Tradeify's section 6.7, profits from the violation period are forfeited "whether or not those profits have been requested for payout".

How do prop firms detect a passing service?

Firms publish their checks, not their hit rate: identity verification, IP and device rules, interviews, audits and account monitoring are all in their terms. Many guides add a check on changes in trading style; no firm page we read describes one, though Tradeify reserves the right to review "the trading activities and styles of all Traders".

  • Identity. Topstep asks for ID photos and a selfie after the first purchase, and its identity verification guide adds: "Additionally, identity verification is also required for requesting Payouts". FTMO requires an FTMO Identity check (KYC/KYB, know your customer) after a pass; FundedNext verifies identity after the challenge phases.
  • Network. The FundedNext Futures Challenge Terms bar different IP addresses for the dashboard and the trading platform without prior approval. The Topstep help center page on prohibited conduct says VPNs, proxy services and TOR are not permitted.
  • Device. FundedNext prohibits operating accounts of different traders on the same device.
  • People. FundedNext "reserves the right to interview the Customer at any time regarding their trading strategies and activities."
  • Records. Tradeify says "The audit may be conducted at any time, without prior notice". Elite Trader Funding says it "actively monitors accounts to detect suspicious activity."

A third party has to clear every check the firm uses, at every stage, for the life of the account. The shared IP and fill mechanics are in how prop firms detect copy trading, and VPN rules firm by firm in our VPN and VPS rules check.

FIVE RINGS FIRMS PUBLISH IDENTITY Topstep, FTMO, FundedNext ID + selfie, again at payout; KYC/KYB after a pass; KYC after challenge phases NETWORK FundedNext, Topstep one IP for dashboard and platform unless approved; no VPN, proxy or TOR DEVICE FundedNext no accounts of different traders on the same device PEOPLE FundedNext may interview the customer at any time RECORDS Tradeify, Elite Trader Funding audit at any time, without notice; account monitoring YOUR ACCOUNT master login THIRD PARTY must clear every ring, every stage Not drawn: a trading-style check. No firm page we read describes one; Tradeify only reserves the right to review trading styles. Firm terms and help pages read 19 November 2026.
Every ring is written into a firm's own terms. What no firm publishes is how often a ring catches a third party.

When does the firm check: during the evaluation, at the funded hand-off, or at payout?

At all three points and any time between: FTMO and FundedNext check identity after the pass and before the funded account, Topstep checks it again at payout, and Tradeify and FundedNext reserve audits and interviews at any time. TraderScale's blog (September 2026) says detection usually comes at the first payout review; that is partly true, since payout is where the money piles up, but it is not the only gate.

Follow one illustrative account down the timeline, each checkpoint taken from the firm that publishes it. You buy a $150 evaluation ($150 spent), pay a $300 service fee ($450) and a $100 activation fee ($550). After the pass, FTMO's verification review typically takes 1 to 4 business days and KYC comes before the funded account, according to the FTMO FAQ for traders who have passed. Funded trading follows, open to audit or interview at any time.

Then the first payout request, an illustrative $1,000, meets Topstep's identity check. If a compliance review places a hold, Topstep's help center says to wait 7 business days and that "When a hold is active: You can't purchase or request Payouts." At that point $550 spent plus $1,000 claimed, $1,550 in total, rests on one review.

MONEY AT RISK ALONG THE TIMELINE $1,000 claimed $550 $1,550 on one review $150 $450 $550 $550 $550 +$300 service fee +$100 activation Buy evaluation Service passes Activation fee Verification and KYC Funded trading First payout request FTMO: review 1 to 4 business days, then KYC before the funded account FundedNext: KYC after the challenge phases Topstep: identity check at payout; on a hold, wait 7 business days any time, any stage: Tradeify audit, FundedNext interview Illustrative: $150 evaluation, $300 service fee, $100 activation, $1,000 first payout.
The gates after the pass arrive once the buyer has already paid both fees. By the first payout request, $1,550 rests on one review.

What happens if you get caught using a passing service?

You lose more than the evaluation fee: the payout, the account and sometimes every linked account go with it. No firm we read says it refunds the evaluation fee after a third-party breach; FundedNext and The5ers say the refund is denied.

The Topstep Terms of Use reserve the right to "delete the trading day and all profits, or restart or close the Account", and to ban the user; Topstep's help center lists a graded range, from a warning to denial of a payout. The5ers: "Any refund or profit will not be processed, and you will be permanently banned from The5ers Fund."

Tradeify places every account involved in violation status, and Elite Trader Funding's household policy lists termination of all accounts linked to the household and forfeiture of their funds. The payout review is covered in why prop firm payouts get denied; a real third-party breach is not something a payout dispute can undo, though a mistaken flag is worth disputing.

Is it illegal to pay someone to pass a prop firm challenge?

We found no regulator, court decision or prosecution that treats it as a crime; the firms frame it as a breach of contract, and the contract is what costs you the account and the payout.

Topstep lists as prohibited conduct "Trading on behalf of others including but not limited to sharing any incentives as part of any business arrangement". When trading for others needs a licence is a separate question, covered in what regulators say about copy trading. Nothing here is legal advice.

Does a passing service ever pay off for the buyer?

Only if your chance of keeping the payout beats a threshold nobody can measure: with an illustrative $550 spent and a $1,000 first payout, you need better than 55.0%, and no firm publishes a detection or denial rate. The table shows what that chance would have to be, not what it is.

First payout (illustrative)Spent before payoutBreak-even chanceValue at 50% chanceValue at 25% chanceBreak-even with 25% service split
$1,000$55055.0%-$50.00-$300.0073.3%
$2,000$55027.5%$450.00-$50.0036.7%
$3,000$55018.3%$950.00$200.0024.4%

Computed by Phoenix Technologies; method: expected value = p x payout - $550, break-even p = $550 / payout, or $550 / (0.75 x payout) with a 25% split. All inputs are illustrative ($150 evaluation, $300 service fee, $100 activation).

Worked through for the first row: $150 + $300 + $100 = $550, paid before any payout. If the $1,000 arrives half the time, you expect 0.5 x $1,000 = $500 back, a loss of $50. Break-even is $550 / $1,000 = 55.0%. If the service keeps 25%, you keep $750 and break-even rises to $550 / $750 = 73.3%.

Picture expected value as a line rising from -$550 at zero chance to +$450 at certainty for the $1,000 payout, crossing zero at 55.0%. Steeper lines for $2,000 and $3,000 cross at 27.5% and 18.3%; dashed versions with a 25% split cross later, at 73.3%, 36.7% and 24.4%. Everything left of a crossing loses money.

WHERE THE BUYER BREAKS EVEN below $0: loss $0 -$550 expected value 0% 50% 100% chance the payout is kept no split service keeps 25% $3,000 $2,000 +$450 $1,000 payout $1,000, 25% split break-even 25% split $1,000 55.0% 73.3% $1,000 $2,000 27.5% 36.7% $2,000 $3,000 18.3% 24.4% $3,000 Illustrative: $150 + $300 + $100 = $550 paid. Expected value = p x payout - $550. No firm publishes p.
The break-even point is easy to compute and impossible to check, because no firm publishes how often a third-party payout survives review.

That chance bundles three events: the service passes, the funded account reaches a payout, and the review does not deny it. The pass rates some services advertise, from 96.8% to "99%+", are their own unaudited claims. And the loss can exceed $550 where a firm terminates every involved or linked account.

Topstep's figures, reported in our pass-rate study, show 16.8% of Trading Combine attempts passed in 2025: 5.95 attempts and $892.86 in expected fees per pass at an illustrative $150 fee. That costs more than $550, but no third-party clause can take the pass back, and 16.8% is an average, not your rate. The wider cost comparison is in prop firm versus your own money.

Can a friend or family member trade my prop account?

No: none of the rules we read makes an exception for unpaid help. FundedNext's definition covers access "whether paid or unpaid", and Elite Trader Funding states: "ETF does not allow one user to trade on behalf of another, whether within the same household or remotely."

What some firms permit is copying your own decisions across your own accounts. FTMO Futures writes: "Copy trading across accounts registered to the same trader is permitted, provided each account independently and fully complies with all applicable trading rules." Tradeify allows the same to the extent its help center permits, while banning mirroring between you and anyone else. Following a paid signal provider is another case, since FTMO Futures also bars trading on a third party's decisions.

The test is who decides and places the orders. If you do, you trade within the rules. If your own trades are copied across accounts all registered to you, it is allowed where the firm permits it, as at FTMO Futures and Tradeify. If anyone else does, paid or unpaid, friend or service, it is third-party trading, banned in all 8 rule sets read.

WHO PLACES THE ORDERS? Who decides and places the orders? You decide and place every order Allowed within the firm's rules Your own trades, copied across accounts registered to you Allowed where the firm permits it FTMO Futures, Tradeify: check the copier rule Anyone else paid or unpaid, friend or service Third-party trading banned in 8 of 8 rule sets read 8 rule sets from 7 firms, read 19 November 2026.
Money changing hands is not the test. The only question the clauses ask is whose decision and whose hands are on the account.

A trade copier such as Thor, which replicates trades from one master account to follower accounts, fits only the second case: it keeps the decision and the accounts with one person, the distinction set out in copy trading versus signals and PAMM. It runs on cloud servers and connects to each of your trading accounts, so check that the firm allows a third-party copier before linking one, and it cannot make anyone else's trading on your account allowed.

A decision rule before you hand over anything

  • If anyone but you would hold your master login or place orders, paid or unpaid, do not do it: all 8 rule sets read forbid it, and 7 extend that to the funded stage.
  • If a service says it needs only a read-only password, it cannot pass anything with one.
  • If you copy your own trades across your own accounts, read the firm's current copier rule first and keep each account inside its own limits.
  • If you keep failing evaluations, the illustrative $300 service fee buys two more $150 attempts of your own, and a pass you earn cannot be forfeited under a third-party clause.

Go deeper

Frequently asked questions

Do prop firms share bans with each other?

None of the 8 rule sets we read mentions sharing a ban with another firm. Some guides talk about industry blacklists, but no firm document we read describes one and no public data shows how bans travel. What 4 of the 8 rule sets do state is a ban or permanent restriction from that firm's own services.

Can I give a coach my login so they can review my account?

Topstep's Terms of Use say you are prohibited from making your login data available to, or sharing it with, any third party. Other firms in our table bar third-party access to the account in similar words. Share exported statements or screenshots instead, and ask the firm if you need anything more.

Is a passing service the same as a signal service?

No. A passing service logs in and trades your account, while a signal service sends trade ideas that you place yourself. FTMO Futures bans incorporating any third party's trading decisions too, paid or free, so a signal can breach the rules even when nobody else touches your login.

Can a company account let several people trade it?

FTMO's CFD rules allow a legal entity to share account access with its employees only if they are members of top management or another body with the highest executive authority. Anyone else trading the account is still a third party under the same clause. Check the firm's current entity rules before adding anyone.

Are the 90%-plus pass rates that passing services advertise real?

They are the services' own claims and nobody audits them. Even a real pass does not settle the outcome, because the firms in our table can still deny the payout or close the account at the funded stage. A pass rate says nothing about whether the money is kept.

Can a firm act after it has already paid me?

The documents we read do not state a time limit. Tradeify forfeits profits earned during a violation period whether or not they were requested for payout, and it may withhold an approved payout that has not yet been paid while a review is open. No firm publishes how often it acts after paying.

What does Earn2Trade ask at checkout about third parties?

By entering your name at purchase, you declare that it is your own name and that you are not trading on behalf of anyone else. Its terms also say only the Account Holder may access the evaluation account or execute trades on it.

How long does FTMO take to review a passed challenge?

According to the FTMO FAQ for traders who have passed, the verification review typically takes 1 to 4 business days. The FTMO Identity check (KYC/KYB) comes before the funded account, so at FTMO that is the first identity gate a third party's pass has to clear.

Sources

  1. Topstep (2026), Terms of use
  2. FTMO (2026), Forbidden Trading Practices
  3. FTMO Futures (2026), Forbidden Trading Practices
  4. Tradeify (2026), Tradeify Evaluation Services Agreement
  5. FundedNext Help Center (2026), What are the Restricted/Prohibited Trading Strategies?
  6. The5ers (2026), Prohibited Trading Practices
  7. Earn2Trade (n.d.), Terms and Conditions
  8. Elite Trader Funding Help Center (n.d.), Policy: Trading for Another User in the Same Household
  9. Topstep Help Center (2026), How Identity Verification Works
  10. MetaQuotes (n.d.), Managing Passwords - MetaTrader 5 for iPhone
  11. FundedNext (n.d.), Futures Challenge Terms
  12. Topstep Help Center (n.d.), Prohibited Conduct
  13. FTMO (n.d.), I have successfully passed, what to do now?
  14. Elite Trader Funding (2026), Terms of Service